Miami Design District and Wynwood Competing for Tri-Rail Station. Which Will Win?

Miami Design District and Wynwood Competing for Tri-Rail Station. Which Will Win?

Nov 28, 2018 November 28, 2018

Cover photo credit: David Santiago

Tri-Rail is coming to Downtown Miami sometime next year. When you consider that South Florida’s commuter rail network is finally accessing South Florida’s urban core, this is big news no matter how you slice it. First, Tri-Rail will head into Downtown Miami by taking an east-west rail line at 73rd Street and then heading south on the Florida East Coast Railway (FECR) tracks, thereby connecting it with the MiamiCentral rail terminal. But this is only the beginning

Tri-Rail is going into Downtown Miami, and eventually, Miami-Dade's east side.
Tri-Rail is going into Downtown Miami, and eventually, Miami-Dade's east side. Photo credit: Bisnow South Florida

Although Tri-Rail will eventually go up the entire FECR line, as part of a project called the Coastal Link, this new connection will immediately give Tri-Rail access to the Design District, Midtown and Wynwood, three booming neighborhoods just north of Downtown Miami. Instead of waiting for the entire Coastal Link, with its dozens of stations that will need to be built across three counties, planners are envisioning building a temporary station quickly. It’s a plan that will get transit results much more rapidly than waiting for the entire line.

This ‘pilot’ station would take about a year to design and construct, said the Miami Herald, with a permanent station to follow. The temporary Tri-Rail station is envisioned under the I-195 overpass, between Midtown and the Design District, and about a block away from 36th Street, where Tri-Rail envisions the permanent station to be located. This would serve as a demonstration station to show the potential success of the Tri-Rail coastal link route, drumming up additional support for the project. This station is already fully funded.

The station would be strategically located between Midtown, which has a significant residential population and also includes shops, restaurants, and offices, the Design District, which is growing with high-end retail, and a new art museum, and Edgewater, which is a booming residential area. That is unless the leaders of the nearby Wynwood Business Improvement District (BID) get their way. They’re vying for the station too.

Tri-Rail Commuter Train
Photo credit: C.M. GUERRERO

In early October, the BID launched a competing proposal to place the station in Wynwood instead. More specifically, at 29th Street, about seven blocks south. They commissioned a study of current and projected growth by urban planner Cesar Garcia-Pons which suggests that NE 29th Street is by far the superior location for a Tri-Rail station. This is because the Wynwood location has a much higher maximum zoned buildout than the Design District location within a half-mile radius, meaning the Wynwood location has the potential to have many more people living and working within walking distance of the station.

Wynwood's proposed Tri-Rail station location
Photo credit: The Next Miami

“As the data contained in this study suggest, there exists significantly higher development capacity in the vicinity of Northeast 29th Street than Northeast 36th Street,” the study said. “And, for the purpose of providing the greatest economic development benefits at the lowest cost to the public sector, a higher development capacity provides a sound statistical basis for siting a Midtown Tri-Rail Station nearer to Northeast 29th Street.”

“The results of the study make a compelling case for siting a commuter transit station a bit further to the south of 36th Street.” Mr. Garcia Pons is quoted in the release.

The study took into consideration the overlapping Midtown area that would be accessible by both stations but says that the Wynwood and southern Edgewater neighborhoods have significantly more allowable development than the Design District and northern Edgewater.

But that’s potential development. Right now, the 29th Street location, although positioned between Wynwood, Midtown, and Edgewater, isn’t really in the middle of anything. With lots of undeveloped land and even some light industry in the immediate vicinity, this proposed station location is a relatively empty spot between three great neighborhoods. The Next Miami has posted the entire proposal to their site.

As Wynwoodians pitch for a station in their neighborhood, it might be appropriate to consider where the permanent station or stations that will eventually replace the temporary one will go. It’s clear the Wynwood BID is angling for the temporary station with an eye that it will become the permanent station location. Right now there’s only enough money budgeted for one ‘temporary’ or ‘pilot’ station though. Eventually, when a line of permanent stations are placed up the FECR tracks, the argument could be made to put stations at 36th Street and perhaps somewhere a little further south than 29th, even closer to the heart of Wynwood.

Strategic Miami Area Rapid Transit "SMART" Plan
Strategic Miami Area Rapid Transit "SMART" Plan

Recent Posts

Miami Beach Vs Fort Lauderdale
Real Estate News Miami Beach Vs Fort Lauderdale
While both Miami Beach and Ft. Lauderdale are sunny and idyllic South Florida locations, there are some key differences between the two that are reflected in the local lifestyle of each area.  If you’re trying to figure out whether you’ll feel more at home in Miami Beach or Ft. Lauderdale, here are some notes to consider about each location. Miami Beach Miami Beach is an island city that many consider Paradise, with a globally-prized local culture and lifestyle, as well as its own municipal government that ensures that Miami Beach residents enjoy every amenity one would expect in a world-class city. Incorporated as a city in its own right, Miami Beach is a separate land mass from the city of Miami, and is connected to Miami by five convenient causeways that lead to the mainland. Not only is Miami Beach the home of the New World Symphony and the Miami City Ballet, as well as the Bass Museum, it is also a mere 20 minutes from Midtown Miami and its famed Arts and Design District on...
Miami’s New and Pre-Construction Condo Update: February 2019
Real Estate News Miami’s New and Pre-Construction Condo Update: February 2019
We know how much everyone loves to save. That is why, starting this month, we will be featuring a special section talking about all the special deals and offers announced on pre- or latest-construction condos in our monthly reports. So, read on and subscribe to stay tuned on all the latest developments in the pre-construction condo space in Miami, and find some special opportunities while you’re at it! Topped-off Monad Terrace – South Beach Pritzker Prize-winning architect, Jean Nouvel’s first built project in Florida has officially topped off. Each of the 59 condo residences in this "reflective building" are designed to offer ocean views. With completion on track for early next year, amenities include a signature water garden comprising of a central lagoon, reflecting pools, adjacent swimming pools, plus climbing gardens, sun deck with pool service, café and juice bar, residents’ lounge, water sports storage and much more. Prices start at $1.7 million, with a choice of two- to...
Buying Miami Condo Foreclosures for Sale: A How-to Guide
Opinions and Advice Buying Miami Condo Foreclosures for Sale: A How-to Guide
Everyone wants a great deal on Miami area condo, and historically there has never been a better way to get a deal than to purchase a Miami condo foreclosure put for sale by a lender or sold at auction. While buying a foreclosure is not for everyone, you will be surprised to find that it is very accessible to almost anyone if you know how to maneuver. In this blog, we will give you a solid overview of what you need to know to get started on buying your next condo in foreclosure and to be able to jump on the next foreclosure condo that comes up for sale. A Quick Overview of How Most Miami Condos Get Foreclosed When an owner fails to pay their mortgage, the bank or lender can file to foreclose on the property at the courts. After going through various legal steps, the courts deliver a final judgment and set an auction date. In Miami-Dade county, once an auction date is set, you can find the property listed here. Keep reading for tips on what to look out for when buying at the county...
Miami Condos That Allow Airbnb
Real Estate News Miami Condos That Allow Airbnb
Airbnb rental property investments are a hot topic all around the U.S, but it is even more relevant in Miami and Miami Beach for a number of reasons. First, given the constant growth of the Miami area, many see Airbnb condo investments as a way to participate in the growth of Miami by creating cash flow while holding onto a property that is likely to continue increasing in value. Second, given the cultural benefits, quality restaurants and nightlife, and year-round warm weather, everyone wants to have a pie de terre here to come at will. Buying into an Airbnb-approved condo that allows daily rentals allows those folks to subsidize their amazing Miami lifestyle. They get the best of all worlds: enjoy Miami and Miami Beach when they want, and make an income when they are away.   Can You Airbnb a Condo? The short answer is, yes, you can buy a condo and Airbnb it. But you need to understand a few key points, starting with whether the condo allows short-term rentals or not. The last...
Intro to Miami Condos with Electric Vehicle Charging Stations
Real Estate News Intro to Miami Condos with Electric Vehicle Charging Stations
Photo credit: Porsche There’re tons of savvy people who wish to go green by switching to electric vehicles, but not having an EV charging station closer home can really put a dent in plans. But, all that’s ready to change! Last year’s amendment to Florida’s Condominium Act really opened up a lot of doors for such eco-friendly vehicles in Miami. The new law, which came into effect on July 1, 2018, gives unit owners the right to install and use an electric vehicle charging station within their condominium building.   New Condo Law Regarding Installation of Electric Vehicle Charging Stations According to this new amendment, condo owners can now go ahead and install a charging station for electric vehicles in the designated parking area of their building (i.e. their assigned parking space). But, those opting to install such EV charging stations would have to do so at their own cost, while staying in compliance with all safety and building codes and have a separate meter for...
How and When to Fire a Real Estate Agent
Opinions and Advice How and When to Fire a Real Estate Agent
One of the most important factors to consider when selling your home is the real estate agent that you hire to sell the house for you, as this person needs to be knowledgeable, dependable, easy to work with, and experienced in achieving successful sales that fulfill the seller’s goals. Sadly, many people hire a real estate agent based on factors that aren’t always the smartest. Perhaps the realtor is a friend of your parents, they helped your neighbor buy their home, or they play soccer on weekends with your brother. But the reality is that not all realtors possess the same skill sets. A real estate agent that focuses on representing buyers will certainly possess a different set of skills from one whose primary focus is selling homes and making money for the seller. An agent that works with luxury single-family residences may not have much experience in selling condominium apartments and vice versa. So it’s important to take the time to interview any agent that you plan to work...