Remember that Casino Project in Edgewater? Saga Continues as Perez takes Legal Action

Remember that Casino Project in Edgewater? Saga Continues as Perez takes Legal Action

Apr 22, 2020 April 22, 2020

Famed local developer Jorge Perez, CEO of The Related Group, has taken his opposition to an approved Miami casino and jai alai fronton in Edgewater up a notch. The namesake behind the Perez Art Museum Miami (PAMM) joined forces with Norman Braman, owner of the Braman car dealership chain, along with two Miami neighborhood homeowner associations to file a lawsuit that aims to block a settlement agreement between the owner of Magic City Casino and the City of Miami. Both Perez and Braman have consistently expressed their staunch opposition to the development of casinos and legalized gambling facilities in Miami, with Perez writing an Op-Ed in the Miami Herald in 2018.

In Miami-Dade Circuit Court, the group, which includes entities controlled by Perez and Braman, as well as the Brickell Homeowners Association and the Morningside Civic Association, sued the City of Miami and its city manager Art Noriega last month with the aim of derailing plans for a proposed jai alai fronton in Miami’s Edgewater neighborhood at 3030 Biscayne Boulevard. Perez, Braman and Design District developer Craig Robins have all previously expressed how gambling in the area would defeat Edgewater’s successful rise to become one of Miami’s most favorite neighborhoods, with a slew of luxury condos having recently been built in the area, bringing families, professionals and second-home buyers.

The lawsuit claims that city officials acted erroneously in approving the zoning request of West Flagler Associates for a pari mutuel facility on a lot owned by developer Russel Galbut’s Crescent Heights. The group is aiming to overturn what they allege is an erroneous interpretation of city code made by zoning administrator Barnaby Min in 2012 that categorized slot machines, pari mutuels and other gambling uses as entertainment.


The filing claims that Min’s interpretation was key to the approval granted to West Flagler Associates, owners of Magic City Casino, who then went on to
obtain approval in 2018 from the State of Florida to open a jai-alai fronton facility, as well as a card room.

Eugene Stearns, the attorney representing the plaintiffs, said that Min’s opinion was not vetted through the appropriate channels in 2012 and noted, “He determined that gambling can take place anywhere in Miami. That requires a development review process that didn’t occur here.”

In a statement released on April 2, Braman stated that the “2012 letter [was] issued in secret and obtained without any notice or process. If the city of Miami is going to allow gambling — and I’ve long said it should not — then notice must be given to Miami’s residents so that they can have a meaningful say and hold elected officials responsible.”

West Flagler Associates asserted that the 2012 letter granted them vested rights that exempted the entity from a city zoning ordinance for the jai-alai fronton that would have required more public hearings. The plaintiffs allege, however, that Min “concealed the 2012 gambling letter, disregarded the zoning code provisions that plainly require notice to other city officials, neighborhood associations, and the public, and thus denied Miami’s citizens any meaningful right to public comment or appeal.”

Jai-alai - Photo courtesy of Samir S. Patel

Jai-alai - Photo courtesy of Samir S. Patel


Additionally, the plaintiffs have filed a motion for intervention in a pending federal lawsuit filed by West Flagler Associates against the City of Miami, which led to the Miami City Commission’s approval of the proposed settlement on February 13. Although Miami Mayor Francis Suarez vetoed the commission’s decision, City Attorney Victoria Mendez responded by issuing an opinion declaring the veto invalid.

Mendez refused to comment on the specific allegations, stating only that “the City Commission’s decision will be defended in court.”

Per the agreement, West Flagler Associates has committed to excluding slot machines from the jai-alai fronton facility. As far as adding the card room, the company is still awaiting Miami City Commission approval for those plans, according to West Flagler Associates attorney Joseph DeMaria. DeMaria noted, however, that if West Flagler is successful in winning this case, the company may then be free to add slot machines without seeking city approval.

Contact Sep Niakan
Founder, Condoblackbook.com & Owner/Broker, HB Roswell Realty
(786) 930-4220
contact@condoblackbook.com
Request Info
By sending you agree to CondoBlackBook's Terms of Use

Your Miami Condo Awaits

Recent Posts

Miami is Open! Check out these Fun Things to Do in June
Lifestyle Miami is Open! Check out these Fun Things to Do in June
For almost two months, Miami hasn’t been quite itself due to the coronavirus outbreak. We’ve missed all the fun events that put the magic in the Magic City. Thankfully, beginning May, the city has started to reopen (including restaurants at 50% capacity and the beaches), and we’re so glad to see some of our favorite hotspots either opening up or gearing up to open in June. So, for our monthly event roundup this time, we’ve got a mixed bag of virtual events as well as in-person events. Here’s looking at the things you can do (online or on the ground) in Miami for the month of June: Virtual Events Deering Estate Virtual Full Moon Yoga: June 4 Taking their monthly full moon yoga class online, yogi Zamanata will be leading a 75-minute Hatha flow session. For $10, you get to experience the transition of the Sun, Moon, and cosmic elements in a refreshing evening class. Those interested should pre-register here, or keep an eye out for when other in-person events come back...
Want to Live in a Penthouse? Here’s What You Need to Know
Opinions and Advice Want to Live in a Penthouse? Here’s What You Need to Know
Penthouses are the pinnacle of condo living. Living in a penthouse means waking up to sweeping views and expansive living spaces that feel like a home in the sky. Add on luxury amenities and, well, now you’re getting the picture. While it might sound cliche and too good to be true, this is the reality of owning a penthouse. But what really is penthouse apartment or condo? And are they worth it? Read on for answers to all of these questions about penthouses. So what IS a penthouse? Penthouses are, historically, a separate build on the very top of an apartment block or hotel, fitted with the best interiors, and both indoor and outdoor space. The term came about in the 1920s when developers started transforming previously undesirable and often dirty “attic” space into incredible and spacious  properties on the top of their developments. Distinguished by their opulence, as well as their world-class views, they were immediately popular and became synonymous with status and wealth (read...
Anatomy of HOA Fees: Are Miami Condo Fees actually High?
Opinions and Advice Anatomy of HOA Fees: Are Miami Condo Fees actually High?
Condo living is often considered more convenient compared to single family houses. Someone else does almost all of your maintenance -- be it the yard, the roof, the pool, you name it. Plus, there’s typically always some kind of security/surveillance. Amenities like swimming pools, gyms and front desks staff are a standard. And, if you buy into a luxury condo, you can get access to full-service spas, wine cellars, golf simulators, lounges, or even art galleries are all part of what you can call home. And while some think there’s a price for these conveniences and little luxuries, the overall cost is about the same as living in a home. The only difference is when living in a condo, you pay one monthly fee for all this, and it’s called your HOA fees or condo fees. Especially in a city like Miami, condos pack in the entire gamut of resort-style amenities fit for a year-round staycation. Not to mention, there’s usually a team of starchitects and internationally renowned designers behind...
Miami is Reopening - Here’s Where, When and How
Lifestyle Miami is Reopening - Here’s Where, When and How
It's the moment we've all been waiting for... after months of carefully staying at home to reduce the spread of COVID-19, Miami begins to reopen as part of a phased process, including real estate offices and showing activities. However, the specific openings and procedures differ slightly between Miami-Dade County, the City of Miami and the City of Miami Beach. So, while you might be tempted to rush out to your favorite restaurant or hair salon, first read below before heading out to know what "Miami's New Normal" is going to look like. And no private business is required to open, so you may want to call your favorite place first. Mayor Carlos A. Gimenez released the official guide to living in The New Normal, allowing many non-essential businesses to open on May 18th. The document covers the basics rules to reopening like requiring everyone to wear face coverings in public, wash hands often, and continue practicing social distancing, along with providing a detailed protocol for...
Love Miami Vice? Mid Century Modern? Miami’s Most Luxurious Vintage and Retro Condo Buildings are Calling
Real Estate News Love Miami Vice? Mid Century Modern? Miami’s Most Luxurious Vintage and Retro Condo Buildings are Calling
While many of Miami’s bold, new constructions are unequivocally gorgeous, the city has a long-standing reputation for charming and delightful architecture, earned by the many fabulous design visions from our colorful, subtropical past. In fact, there are still many Miamians and design aficionados among us who, in fact, prefer the classic and timeless appeal of living in a historic or vintage edifice over the temptation of the super luxe and brand-spanking-new buildings sprouting up.  Older buildings also come with time-tested, solid construction, combined with the aesthetic charm of architectural design, complete with materials and finishes, from a bygone age. Another bonus of some of Miami’s art deco, mid century modern and retro condo buildings is they often have larger floor plans.  For those interested in learning more about Miami’s top vintage condo buildings, read on… Art Deco: A Miami Beach Legacy (1930’s - 1940’s) The Carlyle Condo Hotel - Miami Beach, FL - Photo...
A No Reserve Auction for a 1000 Museum Condo? You Bet!
Real Estate News A No Reserve Auction for a 1000 Museum Condo? You Bet!
With the global health crisis forcing businesses to get creative in the way they cater to their clientele, here’s a rare opportunity: A no reserve auction for a 4-bedroom condo at the coveted One Thousand Museum building, designed by the late Zaha Hadid. Solutions such as online auctions allowing you to bid on luxe properties from anywhere in the world could be a welcome adaptation - and are something that we’ll probably see more of, staying past the after-effects of the COVID-19 pandemic. So, What’s on Sale?  ConcerigeAuctions.com has listed a half-floor, 4,876 sq. ft. condo residence in the landmark One Thousand Museum at 1000 Biscayne Boulevard, in Downtown Miami. Unit 3601, the property features 4 bedrooms, 5 full baths, 1 half bathroom, plus sweeping eastward views of Biscayne Bay, the AmericanAirlines Arena and South Beach. Perched on the 36th floor, the winning bidder will have the perfect spot to soak in unobstructed water views from within their wraparound glass-railed...