Surfside vs Sunny Isles Beach: Which Miami Neighborhood is Better?

If you love coastal living with walkable access to Atlantic Ocean beaches, and you want to move to a beachfront address while bypassing the hustle and bustle of South Beach, there are two beachside communities to consider when looking to make your move: Sunny Isles Beach and Surfside

While these communities are practically next-door neighbors (with ritzy Bal Harbour nestled between them) and they share many amenities, including direct beach access to the Atlantic. Plus, they both are in prime locations that provide quick and easy access to airports, shopping, arts and culture, and outdoor living, living there could not be more different from one another.  

As insiders who’ve lived in these popular Miami neighborhoods, we’ve broken down the similarities and differences between these two beautiful seaside communities in case you are looking to move to Miami.


Lifestyle: Sunny Isles Beach vs. Surfside

While Sunny Isles Beach and Surfside both provide residential coastal living experiences, the two differ primarily in the types of housing and building construction that are available in each area. Sunny Isles Beach is home to more resort-condominium and luxury towers, including the newly completed Residences by Armani/Casa, Regalia, Turnberry Ocean Club, and the Ritz-Carlton Residences Sunny Isles.

Turnberry Ocean Club

Conceptual rendering - Turnberry Ocean Club


Surfside being primarily an enclave of single-family residences, and retains some vintage feel from Miami’s heyday. It’s a little bit more sleepy of a community than Sunny Isles and is less dense. While both neighborhoods are great for families, Surfside has a more traditional small-town feel and local activities revolve around its Community Center, with swimming pools for both adults and kids, and civic activities that unify the community. Still, there are also some new, boutique luxury oceanfront buildings in Surfside, like
Arte by Antonio Citterio (where Ivanka and Jared Trump have been living) and Fendi Chateau Residences, and their scale and size reflect the community vibe.

Arte by Antonio Citterio

Conceptual rendering - Arte by Antonio Citterio


Business: Sunny Isles Beach vs Surfside

Both areas are home to several high-end restaurants and elite small businesses, such as unique fashion boutiques, hair and nail salons, and fitness and yoga centers along Collins Avenue, but Sunny Isles Beach has far more commercial activity than Surfside. There are also businesses in the lobbies of many of the condo buildings and hotels in the area.

AQ by Il Mulino

AQ by Il Mulino in Sunny Isles Beach


While neither of these two neighborhoods will put you in the thick of a corporate business district with commercial office spaces all around you, both are within a close enough distance to areas such as Downtown Miami, Aventura, and Brickell, where office spaces are far more abundant and small private professional service businesses flourish. Many professionals live in these areas precisely to avoid living in the midst of the busy areas where they work. Commuting to and from Downtown Miami and Brickell is definitely doable and you can easily drive to and from work in less than 30-45 minutes from both locations. 


Walkability and Transportation: Sunny Isles Beach vs Surfside

If you enjoy walking and biking about town, in Sunny Isles Beach you can walk to the beach and to commercial shopping areas, as well as to local parks. Surfside is meticulously designed to provide a small-town feeling with safe, quiet streets offering plenty of walkability and providing a pleasant place to ride around on your bike.

Casual living

Photo by Florida Guidebook on Unsplash


While it’s easy to get around without a car within each of these two neighborhoods, and you can walk to such places as Publix, Walgreens, and local restaurants, you’ll probably need a car to venture to other parts of Miami, particularly if you work in areas such as Brickell, Downtown Miami, and Aventura. For those who work in South Beach, commuting by bus may be an option. Both Sunny Isles Beach and Surfside provide easy access to Collins Avenue and the buses that service the general Beach area and can transport you between the Beaches and the Miami mainland.

Looking to live car-free? Don’t miss our article on other Miami neighborhoods where you can live without a car.


Parks and Greenspace: Sunny Isles Beach vs Surfside

The great outdoors in both Sunny Isles Beach and Surfside centers around the Atlantic Ocean and its glittering turquoise beaches. Both areas have several areas for direct beach access and are also close to Haulover Park, where a large grassy park with shady picnic areas borders the Atlantic seashore. Sailing and swimming are regular pastimes at Haulover Park, where there is also a boat launch. You can even rent a ride on a fishing boat and enjoy a deep-sea fishing adventure. Finally, at Haulover Beach, there’s even a clothing-optional beach for those who want to banish all tan lines.

Town Center Park

Town Center Park


Sunny Isles Beach has several parks, including Heritage Park, which spans 4 acres and provides shady greenspace as well as two children’s playgrounds and a leash-free dog park. At Senator Gwen Margolis Park, known for its active soccer field, you can also enjoy shady picnic areas. Town Center Park has a great fitness trail as well as shady gazebos where you can enjoy a picnic, and the newer 5-acre Gateway Park 5 boasts a beautiful butterfly garden as well as a performing arts stage where concerts and other activities take place.

Surfside Beach

Photo courtesy of Miami and Beaches


If we are talking about the beaches, while Surfside is dotted with small neighborhood parks that provide playgrounds for children, the beach at Surfside is reputed to be among the best beaches in all of Miami, because of its calm and tranquil shore, unspoiled by tourist traffic or concessions. In fact, Surfside Beach is so tranquil that sea turtles regularly build their nests there, and the community is united in the protection of these delicate yet majestic sea creatures.

If you want a little more activity while you’re at the beach, Sunny Isles Beach may be more up your alley, as you can rent jet-skis and enjoy lounge chairs, umbrellas, and food and beverage concessions in some areas. The pier at Newport Beach is also a great fishing spot.


Arts and Culture: Sunny Isles Beach vs Surfside

Both Sunny Isles Beach and Surfside are quiet residential areas where little happens in the way of cultural events the likes of which areas like Wynwood and the Design District are known for. However, both communities are close to Miami Beach and all of its cultural offerings, including the Fillmore Theater, the Bass Museum, and the yearly Art Basel art fair held at the Miami Beach Convention Center. Sunny Isles Beach also presents an Annual Jazz Festival, during which you can enjoy fantastic music under the stars.


Photo courtesy of PatWhite.com


Eating and Shopping: Sunny Isles Beach vs Surfside

Sunny Isles Beach has several shopping centers. At the RK Village Plaza, you can enjoy Middle Eastern fare at Chayhana Oasis, authentic Cuban food at El Tropico, and sizzling Argentinian steaks at La Barra. The health-conscious can enjoy a bounty of healthy treats at Sproutz, Miami Juice, and the famed Epicure Restaurant and Gourmet Market. Fine dining is exquisite at Acqualina Resort, and the Beach Bar at Newport Pier provides a great place for a nightcap or an afternoon cocktail.

Beach Bar

Beach Bar at Newport Pier


Surfside has somewhat fewer offerings, but the quality of its eateries is unparalleled, with some locations delighting locals for decades. At Specchio and Café Ragazzi, Italian fare is prepared with finesse, and the ever-popular Sushi Republic is a local favorite for affordable lunches and family dinners. Rustiko serves up kosher fare, and the Grand Beach Hotel as well as the Surf Club provide exquisite fine dining options. Surfside is also walking distance from Bal Harbour Shops, where high-end dining and shopping options abound.


Schools: Sunny Isles vs Surfside

Both Sunny Isles and Surfside are served by highly-ranked public schools in Miami Beach, including Bay Harbor Elementary School, Nautilus Middle School, and Miami Beach Sr. High School. Private school options for both locations include private parochial schools such as St. Patrick’s and the Hebrew Academy, and Lehrman Community Day School and Miami Country Day School.

Miami Country Day School


Architecture and Housing Options: Sunny Isles vs Surfside

Sunny Isles Beach is an expanding neighborhood that has been transformed by new luxury developments in recent years, some of which have broken sales records in terms of property values.  The area is home to several resort-condominium communities where you can live as if you were on vacation full-time. Many of the newer condos provide an unprecedented array of amenities such as in-suite elevators, floor-to-ceiling glass walls that provide breathtaking ocean views, infinity pools, fully-equipped on-site fitness centers, and beauty salons, health spas, and yoga studios all within a few steps of your front door.  There are also some more affordable older buildings in the neighborhood with fewer amenities but with fabulous views and walkable beach access.  

By contrast, Surfside is a coastal suburban neighborhood mainly consisting of single-family residences with manicured lawns and quiet streets where children can play outdoors undisturbed. Ideal for families, Surfside is for those who’ve always dreamed of owning a house by the beach. Neighbors are considerate and quiet, and tranquil living is the order of the day. For those not ready to take on the responsibilities of owning a house, there are a few beautiful condo buildings in the area that allow you to enjoy the best of residential living with world-class ocean views and amenities.

Here are some of the available condos in Surfside, and Sunny Isles Beach.


Cost of Living: Sunny Isles Beach vs Surfside

Both Sunny Isles and Surfside are affluent communities that attract high-end investors and those seeking the combination of luxury, tranquility, and beach access.  Average listings in Sunny Isles Beach range around $1,260,000, or $514 per square foot; however higher-end listings have broken records with listings as much as $172,500,000 or $22,959 per square foot for massive penthouse properties. 

Surfside listings average about $2,264,692, or $857 per square foot, but higher-end properties may list for as much as $32,950,000 or $5,806 per square foot.


Which Neighborhood is Better? Sunny Isles Beach or Surfside?

This decision will depend on what type of lifestyle you want.  If you love the idea of living in a quaint small town by the ocean, with all of the advantages of being within minutes of a sophisticated urban community, Surfside might be your cup of tea. 

If you want to enjoy this same suburban tranquility but can’t resist high-end amenities and dazzling views of the ocean with more activity around you, you might be happier in Sunny Isles Beach.

To see more of our Miami neighborhood comparisons, check out the following: 



At Condo Black Book, we know Miami inside out and we’re here to help you choose a home that is truly perfect for you.  Let us be your guide to beautiful properties in the neighborhoods that you’re most interested in.

LET'S GET SOCIAL!
Connect with us on Instagram and Youtube.

Cover photo courtesy of Miami and Beaches
Contact Us
Sep Niakan
Broker / Team Lead
(305) 697-7667
sep@blackbookproperties.com
Request Info
By sending you agree to CondoBlackBook's Terms of Use

Your Miami Condo Awaits

Recent Posts

The Residences at 1428 Brickell Video Tour: Exquisite, Eco-conscious Living with Italian Luxury
Video Blog The Residences at 1428 Brickell Video Tour: Exquisite, Eco-conscious Living with Italian Luxury
Brickell, the Wall Street of the South, one of the most desirable Miami neighborhoods for international business professionals and families alike, is synonymous with innovation, a luxury lifestyle and original ideas. This time, the Brickell spirit is embodied in the fantastic new pre construction condominium — The Residences at 1428 Brickell.  In our latest video, Stephanie Bienstock, our director of Luxury Sales, visited the newly opened sales gallery to talk with Jennifer Behar Cervera about what makes The Residences at 1428 Brickell unlike any new residential development coming to Brickell, Miami. Join us as we learn about the project’s six driving forces — detail, craftsmanship, architecture, nature, privacy, and innovation — and tour the sales gallery to see all the finishes and details up close.     — What You Can Expect at The Residences at 1428 Brickell, Miami  If you care about the environment and love leaning into Italian design, then the first-ever solar-powered...
February 2024: Miami New Development and Pre-Construction Condo Update
Real Estate News February 2024: Miami New Development and Pre-Construction Condo Update
Miami’s pre-construction market buzzed in February with many newsworthy events throughout the city. The much-awaited Bentley Residences, Cipriani Residences, and Indian Creek Residences and Yacht Club all broke ground this month. And Brickell’s Mercedes-Benz Places, Key Biscayne’s Key Cassa, and Sunny Isles’ St. Regis' second tower launched sales.  Also, developers accelerated construction efforts for several luxury condo projects including Una Residences, 501 First, St. Regis Brickell, and more. Read on for details on these and more exciting updates in our monthly Miami pre-construction condo market roundup for February 2024: Launched Sales Mercedes-Benz Places – Brickell St. Regis Residences (North Tower) – Sunny Isles Beach Key Cassa – Key Biscayne New Sales Gallery Bay Harbor Towers – Bay Harbor Islands Broke Ground Cipriani Residences – Brickell Indian Creek Residences and Yacht Club – Bay Harbor Islands Bentley Residences – Sunny Isles...
February 2024: Fort Lauderdale and Palm Beach Pre-Construction Condo News Update
Real Estate News February 2024: Fort Lauderdale and Palm Beach Pre-Construction Condo News Update
South Florida's pre-construction market continues to stay hot with five new condo projects launching sales this February. Newgard’s Natiivo, Stephen Ross’ Shorecrest, and Sympatico’s Mr. C Hotel and Residences are a few of the announcements that made headlines this month in Fort Lauderdale and Palm Beach. Further, given the demand for luxury housing in Fort Lauderdale and surrounding areas, luxury apartment towers Circ Residences and Havn Residences & Yacht Club converted to condos, offering the first few buyers unique benefits. Read below to find details on these and more projects in our February 2024 pre-construction condo market round-up for Fort Lauderdale and Palm Beach: — February 2024 – Fort Lauderdale & Palm Beach Condo Pre-Construction Market at a Glance Sales Launched Natiivo Fort Lauderdale – Fort Lauderdale Shorecrest – West Palm Beach Mr. C Hotel & Residences – West Palm Beach Glass House – Boca Raton Havn Residences & Yacht Club (Renovated) –...
Oceanfront Luxury: Ritz-Carlton Sunny Isles Penthouse Video Tour
Real Estate News Oceanfront Luxury: Ritz-Carlton Sunny Isles Penthouse Video Tour
Living at the Ritz-Carlton Residences, a global collection of branded condo homes known for their unparalleled service and elegance, offers you the epitome of a luxury-driven lifestyle. And even more so at their prestigious Sunny Isles Beach location, where pristine water views offer serenity in almost every direction. In our latest video, Stephanie Bienstock, our Luxury Real Estate Specialist, takes us on a tour of one of her client’s turnkey penthouses. Come take a look!     Perched on the 48th floor, this exquisite beachfront penthouse residence is an exclusive sanctuary of comfort. Upon arrival, a private elevator whisks you directly into your foyer, an entrance that sets the tone for the rest of the home. Spanning an impressive 2,200 square feet, every inch of this Ritz-Carlton Residences Sunny Isles penthouse has been crafted for an unrivaled living experience, tastefully decorated with a sophisticated color palette and high-end furniture.  Once inside, the open floor plan...
Condo Painting Dos and Don’ts
Opinions and Advice Condo Painting Dos and Don’ts
Painting your home can be a daunting prospect, from the color selection to cleaning up the mess. After all, it is a complex procedure — who knew there were 52 shades of white?!—, and whatever color you do end up choosing will dictate the mood and feel of your entire condo or home, so no pressure! However, when done right, a good paint job is a relatively easy way to renovate your condo and give it a well-needed facelift before selling it, renting it out, or enjoying living there. So, grab your paint color samples, and let’s discuss some condo painting ideas to get your property in tip-top shape. — What Color Should You Paint Each Room? At the end of the day, you should paint your house in whatever color floats your boat! You have to live there, after all. That being said, there are definitely good and bad paint colors, depending on your needs and purpose. The colors and combinations you choose will ultimately have an impact on the look, and more importantly, the feel of your...
New Mercedes-Benz Places Comes to Brickell, Miami
Real Estate News New Mercedes-Benz Places Comes to Brickell, Miami
What do Porsche, Aston Martin, Bentley, and now Mercedes-Benz have in common? They all have luxury condo projects in Miami! And that means you can also call this newly announced Mercedes-Benz Places home.  Announcing its first branded residential project in the U.S., Mercedes-Benz will now have a “towering” presence in Miami. After the successful debut of the Porsche Design Tower, near-complete Aston Martin Residences, and under-construction Bentley Residences, one of the world's oldest carmakers is gearing up to elevate condo living in Brickell with Mercedes-Benz Places. Developed by JDS Development Group, the company behind Echo Brickell, Monad Terrace, and 888 Brickell by Dolce and Gabbana, Mercedes-Benz Places will offer 791 luxurious residences set in a 67-story high-rise. Located at 191 S.W. 12th St., the mixed-use tower will also deliver 200,000 square feet of office/health and fitness facilities plus a 174-key Treehouse Hotel. Adding to the future-ready appeal of the...